Why the Best CV Doesn't Always Win the Legal Job
By Andrew Inglis, Founder of Inglis Legal Recruitment | October 2026
A strong CV gets you into the room. It does not always get you the offer.
I have interviewed and represented many lawyers over the years who look excellent on paper. Strong academic backgrounds. Experience with highly regarded firms. Interesting transactions, disputes and clients. The right number of years qualified. Clear technical skills.
And yet, when a law firm has two or three credible candidates in front of it, the person with the strongest CV does not always get the job.
The reason is simple. Once a firm is satisfied that someone can do the work, the conversation changes.
It becomes less about what they have done and more about how they have done it, what they have contributed and how they will work with the people around them.
That matters more in the current market.
Over the past six to twelve months, I have noticed firms becoming increasingly selective about recruitment. Vacancies are taking longer to approve. Firms are questioning whether certain roles need replacing. Where they do decide to hire, there is often much greater scrutiny around what that individual will bring to the team.
This is not consistent across every practice area. Some teams remain exceptionally busy. Others are experiencing a quieter period.
But one theme is clear from the conversations I am having.
Being technically capable is important. Being able to demonstrate your value is increasingly important too.

When three lawyers can all do the job, what separates them?
One of the questions I am often asked is what makes a candidate stand out when several people have similar qualifications and experience.
My answer is rarely just technical ability.
Of course, that matters. A corporate lawyer needs to understand transactions. A disputes lawyer needs to understand procedure, strategy and evidence. A real estate lawyer needs to know how to manage matters properly and protect the client’s position. Nobody is suggesting that technical skill is optional.
But by the time a candidate reaches interview, the firm has usually already decided that the CV is credible.
The real question becomes different.
A firm starts asking:
Will this person strengthen the team?
Can they manage pressure sensibly?
Do they take ownership?
Can they communicate with clients?
Will partners trust them with important work?
Do they understand what their contribution actually is?
Are they moving for the right reasons?
These questions are harder to answer from a CV alone.
A CV might say that someone worked on a high-value transaction. It will not always explain whether they ran key parts of the process, solved problems, managed the client, supported junior lawyers or simply had their name on the deal list.
That is why interviews matter.
They give firms a better sense of the person behind the document. They also reveal whether the candidate understands their own experience well enough to talk about it clearly.
A strong CV creates interest, but evidence creates confidence
Many lawyers undersell themselves in interviews because they describe experience in broad terms.
They say things like:
“I worked on a range of corporate transactions.”
“I assisted on complex litigation.”
“I have experience with commercial contracts.”
Those statements may be true, but they do not tell the interviewer enough.
A better answer gives shape to the experience. It explains the role played, the judgement used and the outcome achieved.
For example, instead of saying:
“I worked on a private equity transaction.”
A stronger answer might be:
“I acted on a private equity-backed acquisition where I was responsible for managing the first draft of the disclosure letter, coordinating input from the client’s finance and operational teams, and dealing with several rounds of comments from the buyer’s solicitors. It was a tight timetable, so I had to keep the process moving while making sure the client understood the commercial points that needed partner input.”
That answer gives the interviewer something useful. It shows responsibility, communication, judgement and organisation. It also suggests the candidate knows the difference between simply being involved and actually contributing.
This is where some lawyers with very strong CVs fall short. They assume the firm will infer value from the names of firms, clients or matters listed on the page.
In a selective market, that is a risk.
The lawyer who can explain their contribution clearly often leaves a stronger impression than the lawyer with a technically better CV who speaks in generalities.
Firms are looking for contribution, not just credentials
There was a time when a strong academic record, a recognised firm and the right practice area experience could carry a candidate a very long way.
Those things still matter. They always will.
But firms are paying closer attention to contribution.
That does not mean every lawyer needs to arrive with a portable client following. For many associate-level roles, that would be unrealistic. It does mean firms want to understand how a candidate will add value beyond completing tasks.
At different levels, that contribution may look different.
For a junior associate, it might mean:
Being reliable under supervision
Drafting accurately
Asking sensible questions
Learning quickly from feedback
Showing good judgement about when to escalate issues
For a mid-level associate, it might mean:
Running parts of a matter with less supervision
Managing client contact appropriately
Supporting trainees and junior associates
Spotting risks before they become problems
Understanding the commercial aim behind the legal work
For a senior associate, it might mean:
Leading matters day to day
Managing client relationships
Supervising others properly
Supporting business development
Showing readiness for the next stage of career progression
A firm will not always use this language directly in an interview. But these are often the things being assessed.
That is why candidates need to prepare beyond the standard CV summary. The best interviews usually feel specific. The candidate can explain what they did, why it mattered and what they learned from it.
The reason for moving matters more than many candidates realise
When a firm interviews a lawyer, it is not only assessing skills. It is also assessing motivation.
This is an area where candidates sometimes create doubt without meaning to.
A lawyer may have perfectly valid reasons for wanting to move. They may want broader work, better training, a different culture, more responsibility, a clearer route to progression or a practice area that better fits their long-term goals.
Those are all legitimate reasons.
The problem comes when the explanation sounds vague, negative or poorly thought through.
For example:
“I just feel it is time for a change.”
“I want to see what else is out there.”
“I am not really sure what the next step is.”
Those answers may be honest, but they do not give the firm much confidence.
A stronger explanation connects the move to the candidate’s development and to the role in question.
For example:
“I have had good experience in my current team, particularly on mid-market transactions, but I am looking for a role where I can take on more responsibility in the deal process and work more directly with clients. This opportunity appeals because the team is active in the areas I want to develop, and the structure seems to offer that next level of responsibility.”
That answer is focused. It is positive. It explains the reason for moving without criticising the current firm unnecessarily.
Firms are wary of hiring someone who appears uncertain. They want to feel that the candidate has made a considered decision.
Cultural fit is not a soft extra
The phrase “cultural fit” can be overused. It can also be misunderstood.
It should not mean hiring people who all think, speak or behave in the same way. Good teams need different personalities, backgrounds and approaches.
In recruitment, cultural fit is better understood as working fit.
Can this person operate well in this team? Will their communication style work with the partners and clients involved? Do they seem collaborative? Are they self-aware? Will they respond well to feedback? Can they deal with pressure without creating unnecessary friction?
These are not minor points.
A technically excellent lawyer who damages team morale, overcomplicates communication or resists feedback can create more problems than they solve.
By contrast, a lawyer who is technically strong, reliable, calm and constructive can quickly become trusted.
That trust is often what firms are really looking for.
They want to imagine the candidate in the team. In client calls. On urgent matters. Working late when needed. Handling a difficult point sensibly. Asking for help at the right moment. Representing the firm well.
A CV cannot fully answer those questions.
An interview can.

Preparation should go beyond reading the job description
Good interview preparation is not about memorising perfect answers. It is about knowing your own experience well enough to discuss it with clarity.
Before an interview, lawyers should be able to answer four questions.
What have I actually done?
Not just matter names or deal values. Think about your specific role. What documents did you draft? What workstreams did you manage? What advice did you give? What problems did you solve?
Where have I added value?
This might be a client relationship, a difficult deadline, a process improvement, a negotiation point, support for juniors or simply becoming someone the team could rely on.
Why am I making this move?
The answer should be honest, positive and connected to the opportunity. Avoid making the interview sound like an escape from your current firm.
Why this firm and this team?
Generic praise rarely lands well. Be specific. Refer to the type of work, the team structure, the client base, the level of responsibility or the direction of the practice.
The strongest candidates usually do not sound rehearsed. They sound prepared.
They can have a proper conversation because they have already thought carefully about their own experience.
The best candidate is often the clearest candidate
When a firm compares candidates at final stage, the decision can be finely balanced.
One candidate may have slightly stronger academics. Another may have trained at a more recognisable firm. Another may have more directly relevant sector experience.
But the offer often goes to the person who gives the firm the most confidence.
Confidence comes from clarity.
A clear candidate can explain their experience without exaggeration. They can describe their role on matters precisely. They know what they want next. They understand the firm they are interviewing with. They answer questions directly. They listen properly. They show judgement.
That does not mean becoming someone you are not. Interviews do not require a performance. In fact, most firms see through that quickly.
It means presenting your experience in a way that helps the firm understand you.
A strong CV may prove that you deserve to be considered. A strong interview helps the firm decide that you are the person to hire.
What lawyers should take from this market
The current recruitment market rewards preparation, self-awareness and substance.
A good CV still matters. It is often the reason a conversation starts. But once the interview process begins, the CV is only part of the picture.
The candidates who tend to perform best are those who can show:
Technical ability
Clear contribution
Sound judgement
Genuine motivation
Good communication
A realistic understanding of the role
That combination is powerful.
For lawyers considering a move, the message is straightforward. Do not rely on your CV to do all the work. Think carefully about the value behind the experience listed on the page.
Ask yourself what a firm would really want to know if it were deciding between you and two other credible candidates.
Then prepare to answer that clearly.
Because in legal recruitment, the best CV may get attention. The lawyer who can demonstrate value, judgement and fit is often the one who gets the job.





Comments